Case Studies
The purpose of the "Case Studies" section is to provide examples of how the social science tools and methods have been used in natural resource management. The case studies originate from journal articles, white papers, and interviews. Information included in the "Case Study" pages includes a summary of the project, including who did it, where, when, and why; major issues addressed; conclusions; lessons learned; associated tools and methods; and next steps. New case studies are always welcome.
Credit: Original HD.gov Content
-
Analyzing the Cost and Benefits of Human Activities for Indonesian Coral Reefs
The methods of cost-benefit analysis and predictive modeling were used by the Coral Reef Rehabilitation and Management Project (COREMAP) to determine and quantify the threats causing depletion of coral reefs in Indonesia. The results indicated that immediate actions need to be taken by the government to stop the depletion.
-
Entrance Fees for Marine Sanctuaries in the Philippines
This study uses comparative research and a survey to determine how much dive tourists would be willing to pay to dive in areas where fishing was prohibited to fund the enforcement of three marines reserves in the Philippines.
-
Forested Areas and a Sense of Place: Comparing the Perceptions of Compact and Metropolitan Urban Populations.
This research project grows out of a belief that, in order for citizens to care about the status of forested areas in the United States, people need to value the range of resources trees provide society. Our study illustrates the extent to which forested areas represent significant and salient components in urbanites’ descriptions of where they live, what activities they engage in, and what their preferences are for valued lifestyles. The study compares interview and psychometric data generated by youths, professional/trade personnel, and elderly residents located in a reasonably small community on the shore of Lake Superior and a similarly sized town in the Chicago metropolitan area. Through the use of established techniques, dominant and shared themes characterizing respondents’ “sense of place” are extracted from their qualitative responses to structured interview schedules; subsequently, these themes are compared with scaled responses to survey questions tapping into the respondents’ affinity for and activities in a variety of built and natural environments. Results indicate that although there are fifteen themes under girding interview responses, a few of which deal with the presence of trees and forests, forested environments do not seem to be salient markers in individuals’ perceptions of where they live. Furthermore, only a few thematic categories, activities, and settings dealing with social and economic concerns distinguish between the two communities.
-
Identifying Communication Networks among Fishermen in North Carolina
This study uses social network analysis and interviewing to determine the most influential or key individuals within the fishing community of North Carolina. The South Atlantic Fishery Management Council sponsored research done on charter, commercial, and recreational king mackerel fishermen in efforts to improve communication between fishermen and the council.
-
Louisiana Recovery Planning Day
This project used survey methods to identify long-term recovery needs of Louisiana communities impacted by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. It provides an example of how an in person survey can be conducted in a public meeting setting. This project allowed organizers to gather extensive input from Louisiana citizens to inform the recovery planning efforts of local, state, and federal entities.
-
MPA Perceptions by Small-Scale Fishermen in Sicily, Italy
This study uses survey research, demographic analysis, and secondary data analysis to determine the effectiveness of management practices and regulations in teo reserves in northwestern Sicily. Results of the research revealed that better management practices would be needed for more effective reserves.
-
Paying for Seagrass Restoration in the Florida Keys
This study uses habitat equivalency analysis (HEA) and nonmarket valuation to determine the restoration costs, as well as the size of the area, treasure hunters needed to pay for damaging seagrass within Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary.
-
Phase I Lake Superior Community Awareness, Review, & Development Project (CARD): United States Communities.
This report summarizes the results of the Phase I Community Awareness Review and Development (CARD) project sponsored by the Lake Superior Binational Program. The intent of the project was to survey knowledge and awareness of issues relevant to the Lake Superior Binational Program (especially the Lakewide Management Plan or LaMP) in order to foster improved decision-making within the Lake Superior basin. Most of those surveyed cited economic concerns as most pressing and environmental concerns as least pressing. When they did focus on environmental issues, the largest percentage of responses indicated respondents were mostly concerned with watershed-related issues (and, to a lesser extent, land-use practices) at a personal, community, state, and lake Superior basin-wide level. Significant numbers of respondents reported little or no knowledge of key LaMP issues, though in only a few instances did a plurality of respondents indicate a lack of concern for the issues of interest to the program. Given these findings, we can assume that future community-based social marketing approaches to educate and persuade citizens in the Lake Superior basin may be modestly successful. At that time, agencies will want to (a) focus on the areas of water, land use, and economics, (b) tailor campaigns to particular community interests, and (c) demonstrate how threats may be averted and economic opportunities capitalized upon in a way that is convenient, efficacious, and economical.
-
Rapid Evaluation of Proposed Marine Conservation District in St. John, US Virgin Islands
This study uses rapid socioeconomic evaluation, content analysis, observation, and secondary data to determine the possibility of establishing a marine conservation district (MCD) south of St. John Island in the U.S. Virgin Islands. This preliminary research gained many recommendations from commercial fishermen and recreational dive organizations concerning the establishment of an MCD
-
Stakeholder Participation in Socioeconomic Analysis of Restoring the Deschutes Estuary
This case study presents an innovative approach to involving stakeholders in restoration of coastal resources. State resource managers conducted focus groups and broader public meetings to gain insight on the social and economic benefits that should be included in a net benefits analysis of restoring the Deschutes Estuary in downtown Olympia, Washington. The stakeholder input was then delivered to professional economists who conducted the net benefits analysis (NBA). This project demonstrates how social science methods such as focus groups can be used to provide the foundation for socioeconomic analyses of coastal resources.
-
Understanding Coral Reef Use: Anglers, Divers, and Snorkelers in the Florida Keys
To complement ongoing biophysical data collection regarding the resilience of coral reefs in Florida, the University of Massachusetts Amherst’s Human Dimensions of Marine and Coastal Ecosystems Program began a project entitled Understanding Coral Reef Use: Anglers, Divers, and Snorkelers in the Florida Keys for the Florida Reef Resilience Program (FRRP) in May 2006.
-
Willingness to Pay in Rocky Intertidal Ecosystems in Orange County, California
This study uses contingent valuation methods to determine visitor’s willingness to pay (WTP) for sandy beaches or rocky habitats of Orange County, California, to reduce habitat disturbance. This study shows how economic methods such as contingent valuation can be applied to justify the need to mitigate natural resources or enforce natural resource laws and regulations.
|
|